Crazy Pizza East Hampton

Saw this place on TikTok, and it looked so fun and I needed to try it. It was easy to make reservations, the food was good, pizzas are very, very thin, and personalized. The only thing that was a little disappointing was the show, it literally lasted 30 seconds, wish it was longer. Also, the price for the amount of food was way more than it should be. So prepare to pay a lot. Would I go back, no really, but def checking it off my list!

Cannot begin to express how much fun Crazy Pizza was and how badly we need something festive like this in our town. What a ball we all had! Fun for all ages and delicious food. Wonderful service and stylish setting. We absolutely loved it and already have a reservation to go back.

Just spent an evening at Crazy Pizza in East Hampton and I seriously can’t stop smiling! This place isn’t just about pizza (even though the pizza is next level delicious ) — it’s about the vibe, the energy, and the people who make it feel like one big, happy party. Amazing staff Kind, welcoming, professional, and so much fun. Shoutout to the managers — You’ve created something so special. If you’re ever in East Hampton — whether you’re local or just visiting — Crazy Pizza is a must. Come for the food, stay for the experience. And if you’re lucky, you’ll get to meet the team that makes the magic happen.

We were excited to check this spot out with a big group (normally I test-run before bringing the entourage, but we went all in this time). The vibe shows promise, though they’re still finding their stride. Our reservation took extra time to turn into actual seats, and while the prix fixe menu was solid enough, it leaned more on "fine" than "fantastic." The drinks, on the other hand, were excellent—just fashionably late. The meal pacing could use some fine-tuning. When we asked to speed things up, we didn’t quite expect mains before starters. Also they need to showcase more pizza types than just variations on margarita. The spicy salami was my personal favorite.

The food was good for the most part. Burrata pizza was solid as was the service. Margherita was pretty good as well. My main criticism on the pizza is they did not cut it well. Also, I know it’s the Hamptons, but I found a lot of the menu to be significantly overpriced. The drinks were $25 each which is just outrageous, even for the Hamptons. The pasta was way too small for $30. The Baba cake was a good dessert but man the Nutella pizza was just terrible. It was undercooked and was literally just Nutella. It should come with strawberries or bananas too for $20. Overall I probably wouldn’t recommend this place to anyone because of the kind of terrible pizza and ridiculous prices.

I travel a lot ans a pilot and love trying new pizza spots, but this was one of the strangest dining experiences I’ve had. The pizza was paper-thin, small, and didn’t have much flavor—definitely not worth the price. I asked to make a small change to my order and was told it wasn’t allowed because the recipe couldn’t be altered. That’s fine if the dish is outstanding, but when the food is average at best, it just feels rigid and out of touch. I’ve never come across a place so unwilling to accommodate a basic request, especially when the product doesn’t live up to the hype. Disappointing overall.

I reached out to crazy pizza in East Hampton when I saw that they were opening and from the start I was in touch with Jessica, who is so nice and so accommodating. I was holding a birthday party for myself with about 18 people and she really helped keep it organized- we had a nice long table in the back by the DJ and it was amazing. The atmosphere is very fun there and it doesn’t feel like a normal dinner. Stefano was our server and he was so nice from the moment we sat down until the moment we left he really made my birthday special. All my friends had nothing but good things To say the. food was amazing we ended up getting family style. Pizza was a little doughy but still good!. My friend ordered a couple bottles of champagne and the servers made it so fun when it came out, they went around the table and poured it into our mouths I definitely recommend going to crazy pizza if you want a fun dinner experience great service, good food!! 🙂