In Between Tavern

📍 Gay bars in Cincinnati

4.4

The In Between Tavern stands as a well-loved local spot in Cincinnati, blending a laid-back atmosphere with a timeless charm that draws in a diverse crowd. Known for its central location, it’s a prime choice for sports fans heading to nearby venues or patrons unwinding after a show. The friendly service often sets a welcoming tone, though experiences can vary depending on staffing.

Inside, the decor and cleanliness contribute to a comfortable vibe, while the outdoor patio adds a relaxed touch. Food options like burgers and wings cater to casual cravings, though drink selections and pricing may leave room for improvement. A solid pick for those seeking an unpretentious, community-driven hangout.

Features and services of In Between Tavern

Service options

  • Outdoor seating
  • Delivery
  • Takeaway
  • Dine-in

Highlights

  • Fast service
  • Great beer selection
  • Great cocktails
  • Sport

Popular for

  • Solo dining

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair-accessible toilet

Offerings

  • Alcohol
  • Beer
  • Cocktails
  • Food
  • Food at bar
  • Happy-hour drinks
  • Spirits
  • Wine

Dining options

  • Seating

Amenities

  • Toilet

Atmosphere

  • Casual
  • Cosy

Crowd

  • Groups

Payments

  • Credit cards
  • Debit cards
  • NFC mobile payments

Parking

  • Paid parking lot
  • Paid street parking

In Between Tavern is in position 48 out of 58 in gay bars in Cincinnati

Customer Reviews

★★★★★
★★★★★

In Between Tavern has a rating of 4.1 out of 5 based on over 155 reviews on Google

Jodie Baker

The In Between Tavern is exactly what a great neighborhood bar should be—fun, welcoming, and full of character. Open since 1969, this longtime Cincinnati staple has clearly perfected the art of bringing people together. It’s an ideal spot for pregame gatherings before a Cincinnati Reds or Bengals game, or for grabbing a drink after a show at the Taft Theatre. The location makes it easy, and the vibe makes you want to stay longer than planned. A special shoutout to Adam, the manager, who was absolutely fantastic. He was welcoming, respectful, and genuinely friendly—setting the tone for a great night from the moment we walked in. The Friday night crowd was eclectic and lively, with a mix of ages—from young to not-so-young—all enjoying themselves and sharing the same easygoing energy. The In Between Tavern isn’t trying to be trendy—it’s busy being timeless. If you’re looking for a place with history, personality, and a guaranteed good time, this is one stop you don’t want to skip. 🍻

Jodie Baker ☆ 4/5
Matthew Norris

Stopped by after work for a drink. 4:15 ish. Only a three options on draft. Stella, blue moon, and something else. Asked if they had any snacks, chips pretzels, etc. But nope. The were waiting for the cook to arrive before they could start offering food. The draft also ended up being full price. Now I didn't go looking for a happy hour discount but a little surprised there wasn't one to try and draw in more business. I'd go back if I was desperate for a drink after work and didn't have other options.

Matthew Norris ☆ 3/5
Tabitha Addy

Fun vibe!! The wings were fatty and tough but fine. Tenders were ok as well. The fries were probably my favorite!

Tabitha Addy ☆ 4/5
Karly Wise

Came here last night with a couple friends before the Cyclones game. Right away we were treated pretty poorly by the female bartender. When we sat down and were talking and deciding what and how we wanted to order, she asked from across the bar "so are you guys gonna order anything or what?". We hadn’t even been sitting down for 5 minutes. I had every intention of walking up to the bar when we were ready to order. We ordered 2 orders of tenders and fries, loaded tots, fried pickles, and a round of drinks. Then, I wanted to order another round before happy hour ended at 7. Granted it was 6:58 but in my experience bar staff are usually 100% okay ringing in an order before the drinks are made to get the happy hour discount. Which is then usually reflected in the tip. She argued with me about it then acted like there was nothing she could do when she rang it up normal price. Finally, when I wanted to close my tab, she mad direct eye contact with me and proceeded to ignore me. When I politely said I just wanted to close my tab, she said "yeah me too" then kept walking to another patron at the bar. This was a really unfriendly experience and I won’t be back.

Karly Wise ☆ 1/5
Hannah Taylor

I wanted to like this place so badly as I love local dives and this seemed to have that vibe from the outside. We went in September (it was unseasonably hot outside) but after walking there, we were very surprised for it to be STIFILINGLY hot inside. Beer was cold which was good but didn't stay cold long even in a koozie. Can't speak for food as we were too hot to stay for more than one drink.

Hannah Taylor ☆ 2/5
Proud Cherokee

Great place! Inside is wonderfully decorated, inviting atmosphere, the entire areas and bathrooms are clean and hygienic. There are surrounding parking meters and parking lots. Easy accessibility. Sits right on the corner, directly across from Great American Ballpark and catty corner from Heritage Bank Center. Beautiful outdoor patio. Very affordable menu and super friendly staff!

Proud Cherokee ☆ 5/5
Michael Daniels

We had lunch I had a riverfront Burger with chips and my son had a beer cheese and bacon burger. Both doubles smash burgers and they were delicious. Very fresh ingredients and I would definitely eat there again and recommend eating dinner.

Michael Daniels ☆ 5/5
View all reviews

Information about In Between Tavern

Address

In Between Tavern is located at 307 Sycamore St, Cincinnati, OH 45202, United States

Website

The website of In Between Tavern is: inbetweentavern.com

Business Hours

Monday: 11:00–01:00
Tuesday: 11:00–01:00
Wednesday: 11:00–01:00
Thursday: 11:00–01:00
Friday: 11:00–02:30
Saturday: 12:00–02:30
Sunday: 11:00–02:30

Contact In Between Tavern

    Similar alternatives to In Between Tavern

    Subir