The MacPherson House

My best friend and I needed a little getaway from the busy holiday season. We stayed at a bed and breakfast together for the first time, the MacPherson House in Fayetteville. It was such a memorable experience. From the moment we arrived, we were warmly greeted by the owner, and Santa! Fun fact: he’s the Santa for the Fayetteville Rotary Parade. We had just missed their Photos and Cookies with Santa event, which made the welcome feel even more special. The owner took the time to share the history of the room we stayed in, the Saint-Avold Suite, which added a thoughtful and personal touch to our stay. The suite itself was cozy and relaxing, with all the basic amenities you could need and the softest rugs, OMG honestly, my favorite part. There was also a cozy nook just outside the room that I could easily picture as a little library or reading nook. We loved having a coffee station right outside the suite, and breakfast was absolutely amazing. The entire house was beautifully decorated with festive Christmas vibes, making it feel warm and magical. The only downside was that it wasn’t quite a "silent night" due to the nearby trains. However, the hosts were very thoughtful and provided both earplugs and white noise machines, which we truly appreciated. Overall, it was a charming, welcoming stay, and we would absolutely consider returning.

The Cottage was a great place to spend a few days with our two small dogs. The space was well thought out and there were plenty of amenities. We did not need anything at all. There are a lot of printed ‘rules’ in the cottage which was the only negative. We are traveling with pets, so they will sometimes jump up… this should be expected when renting a pet friendly location. Other than that the stay was amazing… it is in the middle of everything and walking distance to most things downtown.

A lovely, charming home with easy self-entry. The bedroom was huge and the bed very cozy. Absolutely spotless as well. There's no TV in the rooms which is a good thing because the sound of it might have carried. The free choc chip cookies on the coffee/tea bar in the hallway were wonderful. The convenient location on a busy street meant that there was traffic noise (and occasional train whistles), but I didn't mind it. I slept like a rock. Breakfast was luscious: hot apple-cinnamon french toast, sausages, and plain yogurt with fresh berries. Service was perfection. I'll be back!

McPherson House is a lovely B&B although it’s more like an old fashioned Inn with sparkling clean, and cozy accommodations. The rooms are incredibly comfortable and the included breakfast is delicious! What a relief to find as an option on our yearly drive from DC to Miami and back for the Xmas holidays. We really dislike the sterile, soulless highway motel chains. We will definitely be returning g to th McPherson House.

There are a lot of nice details in room decor. We were served a wonderful breakfast. Katy was very accommodating with our reservation. Because of weather we could not be there the night we reserved. She allowed us to change to another night. Only negative was train noise.

Beautifully appointed and well run B&B very conveniently located. I stayed in the only first floor room. I appreciated the easy access/fewer stairs and the bonus was being right across from the complementary snack bar which included coffee, teas, water, muffins, yogurt and chocolate chip cookies. The full breakfast offered was filling and satisfying. I enjoyed chatting with other guests, and the staff was very welcoming and friendly. Only a few blocks drive from restaurants. I enjoyed the Innkeeper’s recommendation of Circa 1800. I also appreciated the offstreet parking to feel more secure about leaving my car in an unfamiliar place.

I do not recommend this place. Poor sleep due to constant noise from a nearby highway and train. The house is pretty but it’s is not worth the price, and owners who overcharged us without our consent and showed zero courtesy or flexibility. For anyone considering staying here: Before booking, I specifically asked by phone if a 30-minute late checkout (11:30 instead of 11:00) was possible. I was told it would cost $50, which I clearly declined. I was then told I could work after checkout in the dining room or common areas. Because I asked (not because they offered). The next morning, I was informed there is no bathroom available outside the room. At 11:00, with the entire house completely empty, no cleaning taking place, and the room door left open, I asked if we could keep access to the room only to use the bathroom while working downstairs. I was allowed by the woman on site to do that. Despite this, $50 was charged to my card without warning or consent for a "late checkout." This felt dishonest and purely motivated by extracting an extra fee, especially given the circumstances. For nearly $300 per night, this level of noise, rigidity, and lack of basic hospitality is unacceptable. We paid an absurd amount to stay less than 12 hours and left feeling taken advantage of. While the house looks nice, the experience is absolutely not worth it.