LDV at The Maidstone

The Maidstone is absolutely perfect for a weekend getaway. The staff is amazing, the rooms are clean, beds comfy, and the free breakfast in the morning is the cherry on top! My mom and I loved our stay here. Thank you Maidstone for your hospitality, we will be back!!

What a fabulous experience. The Maidstone Inn was lovely!! From my upgraded room, to the breakfast/coffee service by the fireplace each morning. Dinner last nite at the Restaurant was one of the best of my life. No kidding! Don’t miss it….Fall in the Hamptons was a real treat, and on my bday coincidentally. Will, Troy & the whole staff made my stay restful, luxurious & I’ll be back w/family soon.

Really excellent! I attended a wedding there last night and it was superb. I’ve been to tons of weddings over the years but have never left a review for the venue but felt I needed to for this one. The grounds are beautiful and so serene, the staff were all excellent - warm, welcoming, helpful - Emma was on point and everyone was really good! I can’t get over the delicious food and the main room for the wedding was just gorgeous and intimate. The whole experience just felt perfectly done. I live and work in East Hampton + Sag Harbor and have been hearing the great reviews over the past year but hadn’t been able to make it there recently. I will definitely be back for dinners, I can’t wait to have the food there again. And anyone considering having an event there should absolutely go with it!

We had a great one night reprieve from the city. I own a home nearby but it is having some work done. Felt like a vacation in my own town! The bar, restaurant and manager on duty were all lovely!

Good location, friendly staff. For our 2 day stay we paid $1,500 for a room (#6) August 2025, that had generators that went off several times during the night and woke us up. Our room also faced the back yard where they had dinner tables set up. Noisy until 10pm - if you wanted to get to bed early forget it. Breakfast was very basic, yogurt and bagels and a little fresh fruit. Definitely not worth the money- must be better places in East Hampton at this price.

Had a great stay on a quiet weekday night. The staff was super inviting. More or less exactly what you would expect for a hotel of this caliber. It felt like you were staying at a family members beautiful home. We really enjoyed it, a lot of charm due to the buildings classical age, the bar and bar staff were very nice. We had a few cocktails and really enjoyed our chat and sitting by the fireplace. The restaurant was also excellent. Great job to Julio and his team. We really enjoyed our meal and hope to come back.

I will preface this review by saying we travel a LOT. We love historic hotels and we will gladly pay money for a nicer hotel and the experience and service that comes along with it. With that said, we just left our week stay at The Maidstone. The good things about our stay - charming and historic atmosphere, located near East Hampton village and the staff member Will - he was incredible. Every business owner should be lucky enough to have such a hardworking, conscientious employee like Will. However the joy stops there. Our room was extremely overpriced for what it was. You might say "welcome to The HAMPTONS", however we visited a few other hotels in the area and for the same price and sometimes even less, the rooms and environment at the other properties were FAR SUPERIOR. For example, our room had no dresser drawers for clothes. Let me repeat - no dresser for clothes. And there was a cheap half circle table that could be removed and a dresser would have fit in the location. The bathroom had one pedestal sink with very little space to put toiletries. There was no magnifying mirror. I would advise to bring your own hairdryer as what they provided was a joke. They claim to be a 4 star hotel, however we would rate them a 3 star at best. The maintenance in the room and property was poor. For example part of our closet door was broken and you couldn’t slide it open to access the full closet, the climate control remote fell off the wall - and throughout - generally the upkeep of the property was poor. They pride themselves on the restaurant but the rest of the property and grounds is definitely underwhelming. You don’t get a feel of cleanliness or care. When we visited the other Inns nearby, they all had TV’s in the rooms - the Maidstone did not. The other properties were very well maintained. The furnishings in the rooms at the other hotels, the cleanliness and care was excellent. The Maidstone is clearly taking advantage of the supply and demand of the HAMPTONS summer season by charging exorbitant prices for what they give you. For 6 nights we paid over $10,000 for a mediocre experience. As we left, we tried to reach someone to help us carry our luggage down from our 3rd floor location. No one answered the main number. It offered an emergency extension which we tried out of curiosity and no one answered that either. I walked downstairs and the girl at the front desk had to go hunt down a guy to carry our luggage down - he left it at the front door. He didn’t even take it out to our car.