What Mary Kept
What Mary Kept stands out as a charming Brooklyn thrift shop blending curated vintage finds with a welcoming atmosphere. Its well-organized selection spans clothing, furniture, and homewares, including standout pieces like mid-century modern cabinets and unique decor—ideal for those seeking both nostalgic and contemporary styles. The store’s thoughtful arrangement and fair pricing make it a go-to for one-of-a-kind gifts or personal treasures.
Located near Jefferson Station, the shop’s cozy ambiance is enhanced by its attentive staff and eclectic mix of music. Whether hunting for rare fashion, functional decor, or sentimental keepsakes, visitors appreciate the careful curation and effortless browsing experience. A hidden gem for vintage lovers and design enthusiasts alike.
Features and services of What Mary Kept
From the business
- Identifies as women-owned
- Small Business
Service options
- Kerbside pickup
- Delivery
- In-store pick-up
- In-store shopping
- On-site services
Offerings
- Buys used goods
Crowd
- LGBTQ+ friendly
- Transgender safe space
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
Parking
- Free of charge street parking
What Mary Kept is in position 39 out of 46 in leather bars in Brooklyn
Customer Reviews
What Mary Kept has a rating of 4.9 out of 5 based on over 23 reviews on Google
What a cute small thrift shop with a ton of cool curated items. It's not too far from Maria Hernandez Park, or Jefferson Station. Cool music playing too.
This quaint shop is a hidden gem! It's an ideal place to peruse when on the prowl for cool clothing and vintage wares that evoke warm memories from your past! The joys that await will re-illuminate the child within. Go! And give yourself permission to ponder the possibilities!
Obsessed with the carefully curated selection of homewares, furniture, and clothes / dreaming of outfitting my new apartment with their Cesca Chairs, MCM cabinet (truly the most stunning piece ever), unique bird coffee table that puts the postmodern mactan craze to shame, and unique glassware and decorations. Also, it feels like they are one of the few vintage stores in the area that provide just as amazing clothes as furniture. While browsing I found a pair of impeccably kept Badgley Miscka heels and walked out with a H BAR C 1950's cowboy shirt in perfect condition. Cannot recommend enough.
An amazing vintage shop right off the Jefferson L. The shop has a great variety of items from furniture to decor to clothes and accessories. All items have clearly been curated and chosen with care and the space feels warm and welcoming. It’s easy to picture bringing any of these items home. 10/10 wonderful establishment
This place is the perfect go to for unique gifts. There are so many wonderful options for a truly one of a kind present for friends , family and sometimes MYSELF!
Love this store. Very well organized. Lots of items and great prices too. Staff was so helpful. Found a lot of things to buy.
Cody is the best! This place is so cute, with a fantastic selection and a backyard! We’ll be back! Fair prices and great vintage
Information about What Mary Kept
Address
What Mary Kept is located at 203 Knickerbocker Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11237, United States
Website
The website of What Mary Kept is: instagram.com/whatmarykept
Business Hours
Monday: 13:00–19:00
Tuesday: 12:00–19:00
Wednesday: 12:00–19:00
Thursday: 12:00–19:00
Friday: 12:00–19:00
Saturday: 12:00–19:00
Sunday: 12:00–19:00