Anthony's Eatalian

Anthony's Eatalian is a lovely neighborhood Italian Cucina that features classic Italian dishes, solid friendly service and a cozy home-like atmosphere with beautiful decor. The Tilapia al Limone and Chicken Parmesan were our choices this time and did. Or disappoint. The lemon sauce on the tilapia was a delicious flavor, as was the classic red sauce on the chicken. Bruschetta appetizer was a wonderful zesty vinegar and tomato flavor to start the evening. Our server, Victor, was a delight and made our experience extra charming. We will be back.

Anthony’s has the best food my family and I come here for birthdays & Celebrations. Victor our server was the best he was very accommodating, warm and welcoming! He did a great job at recommending the best entrees & appetizers for my mom’s birthday! Definitely a 10 out of 10!!

The new location is larger but I didn’t see any outside seating. I noticed a change in the garlic bread. It wasn’t as good as the bread I had at the other location. My house salad was Ok. My lasagna was delicious. I also had a slice of lemon cello cake. It was very good. I also got a pizza to go. The crust was really good. The pizza was good also. My friend had meatloaf with mashed potatoes and fresh vegetables. She said everything was delicious. She got the eggplant Parmesan to go. I don’t know if it was good because I haven’t talked to her about it yet. Our waiter was okay. He seemed to be just doing his job and not concentrating on providing excellent service. I like his restaurant so I will be going back.

This is a review for my first visit. This restaurant was recommended by a close friend and I had high hopes. When you walk in you'll notice its quite cute. My friend an I got waters and sangrias to start off with an order of calamari. I wanted a white wine sangria and she wanted a red, we both got white... she said no big deal I'll drink it. Next we got bread brought to the table after maybe 10 mins of us being there. 3 mins after the bread we got our calamari whilst enjoying our bread. The server cleared the bread when he dropped off the calamari which was extremely weird as we hadn't ordered our meals yet. We placed our food order and started on our calamari. Unfortunately the calamari which we both were excited for was overcooked and oily, batter fell off as if it had been refried. The texture was very hard and chewy. We finally received our main dishes and sent back the calamari as it was inedible. We were weary of the main dish but they looked delicious and we were starving so we dug right in. To our surprise the mains were exceptional. I went with the pesto salmon dish and she had the baked ziti. I dont know if they were as great as I think they were or if maybe we were just hungry. I will definitely have to come back and revisit my review.

I should’ve taken a picture of the veal piccata that I got it was beautiful and the roasted potatoes and vegetables were just as good. The sauce was rich, The veal was tender and seared. My daughter‘s bowtie pasta marinara, and meatball were perfect. She said it was the best meatball she ever had. The service was great, this place should be packed all the time. Thank you for a good time.

This is now the third or fourth time I’ve come back to Anthony’s, I always get the veal piccata, I love the sauce. I love the capers. Today it was perfectly cooked, the vegetables were roasted perfectly. The veal was lightly crispy, and the sauce was exquisite. Victor served me, and he was great, but really even the other waiters came and helped when he was tied up with another table. It’s a laid back atmosphere, and I definitely will be back! I should’ve taken a picture of the veal piccata before I finished it so no pictures today. But my plate was clean.

Anthony’s is seriously next-level when it comes to Italian food! Every single dish is a win, but the Cioppino has my heart — rich, loaded with fresh seafood, and packed with flavor. And that cranberry & pecan salad? Total vibe. 🥗💯 The service is always on point, the place is spotless, and the food is as fresh as it gets. If you haven’t been, run… don’t walk. Your taste buds will thank you! 🍝🔥