Paddy Coynes Irish Pub

This place has the most indulgent and delicious chocolate cake thing I've ever had in my life. I will return just for this. Other dishes were lackluster. Stew was watery and salad was unexciting. Atmosphere is good, but could use some floor to ceiling curtains to block out the lights from the Lincoln Square entrance.

A wonderful experience at Paddy Coynes Irish Pub this afternoon. Unfortunately, the Seattle Mariners versus the Detroit Tigers Post-Season game had a few hour "rain out", so we didn't see the game at the pub. However, our waiter Brandon was a perfessional, and was clear with his communication about the oven having potential problems, and needing a reset, and test cycle before they could cook their signature Shepherd's Pie dish. After only less than ten minutes, they were able to fulfill the order. The Shepards Pie and Fish & Chips dishes were excellent and authentic. By the way, as an Irish person, my Guinness was poured to perfection, as well. Mad props to the bartender for creating the perfect pour of a Guinness that I have seen since going to Dublin. I can't wait to come back! 💚

We had the shepherds pie and 1/2 Ruben sandwich with fries. Shepherds pie was really good. Ruben could have had more dressing but was great too. The Guinness was poured to perfection that even this non beer drinker noticed. Highly recommend the single scoop praline ice cream for dessert. It's a great size to share at $6. When all other restaurants were at an hour wait we walked in at 730p and got a table. Staff was attentive too. There was an annoying fly but not too bad.

Paddy Coyne’s offers great service and a diverse menu, making it a solid choice for any occasion. Don't miss the cheese sticks appetizer – they’re packed with gooey goodness! For the main course, the bangers and mash are a standout, with in-house mashed potatoes that are rich and flavorful. The fish and chips, though, were a bit underwhelming, but still decent. Overall, a great spot for a casual meal with some hits and a few misses.

We had some special requests for our food and they were Very accommodating. The food was Excellent. Our server was exceedingly kind and patient. The other patrons were friendly and there was a warm atmosphere on a cold rainy night.

Horrible food night. I’ve ate here before but tonight was a whole new level. Potato skins undercooked with sloppy Joe on top. Disgusting mashed potatoes with dried out fried chicken on top and service no time to address the issues. Even bringing the food without utensils. Thank god the beers are always good or else I would never come here again.

I love Irish food and this restaurant is awesome. I will keep updating this rating because I am going to keep coming back to try everything on the menu. I love that they also have side plates and small plates so you can try all different things. We got the Shepherd's Pie, Guinness Beef Stew, side of corned beef and side of fries. 10/10. Ve try good prices, the food comes out fast, and the food is very good. Very very happy and will be back.